Petro for McDavid

1
Curious what you posters think. There was an article on Hockeybuzz about Edmonton making a trade (philosophically) with the top pick, if they end up with it, for a defenseman. It hurts that we don't have a first rounder. I was wondering if this might be a good trade for both sides. It does leave us with a hole on defense, but it gives us a stud franchise center.

Re: Petro for McDavid

3
hockey jedi wrote:Curious what you posters think. There was an article on Hockeybuzz about Edmonton making a trade (philosophically) with the top pick, if they end up with it, for a defenseman. It hurts that we don't have a first rounder. I was wondering if this might be a good trade for both sides. It does leave us with a hole on defense, but it gives us a stud franchise center.
I would do this straight up right now, tomorrow, the draft, next season after his first full season, etc..etc. and so on and so forth.

Re: Petro for McDavid

4
I'llBeBackes wrote::lol: That wouldn't even come close to getting the job done
I would say it's not as far away as you state, but you are right, they wouldn't do it straight up. It would probably take a swap of first rounders (which we don't have) and Petro.

Re: Petro for McDavid

9
hockey jedi wrote:Curious what you posters think. There was an article on Hockeybuzz about Edmonton making a trade (philosophically) with the top pick, if they end up with it, for a defenseman. It hurts that we don't have a first rounder. I was wondering if this might be a good trade for both sides. It does leave us with a hole on defense, but it gives us a stud franchise center.
I'll toss in Petro's Airfare and moving costs.

I'd even give them Steen.

Re: Petro for McDavid

15
39hurricane wrote:It would take a kings ransom to get the 1st pick. Look what the Nordiques got from Philly for Lindros.

And the Diques/Avs got the cup.

If you want the 1st pick its Petro Schwartz Fabbri and a pick.

Pass
I think we'd have to toss in a goalie too.

Re: Petro for McDavid

16
39hurricane wrote:It would take a kings ransom to get the 1st pick. Look what the Nordiques got from Philly for Lindros.

And the Diques/Avs got the cup.

If you want the 1st pick its Petro Schwartz Fabbri and a pick.

Pass
If that's the price, let them keep the pick. How about Cole and ...... oh.... wait.

Re: Petro for McDavid

17
LrdStnly wrote:
39hurricane wrote:It would take a kings ransom to get the 1st pick. Look what the Nordiques got from Philly for Lindros.

And the Diques/Avs got the cup.

If you want the 1st pick its Petro Schwartz Fabbri and a pick.

Pass
If that's the price, let them keep the pick. How about Cole and ...... oh.... wait.
Rattie is the new Cole

Berglund, Rattie, and a 3rd

Re: Petro for McDavid

18
bluetuned wrote:
LrdStnly wrote:
39hurricane wrote:It would take a kings ransom to get the 1st pick. Look what the Nordiques got from Philly for Lindros.

And the Diques/Avs got the cup.

If you want the 1st pick its Petro Schwartz Fabbri and a pick.

Pass
If that's the price, let them keep the pick. How about Cole and ...... oh.... wait.
Rattie is the new Cole

Berglund, Rattie, and a 3rd
Let's not overpay here....